• Home
  • Portfolios
    • El Agua es La Vida: A Village Life Portrait
    • Exit West: A Cultural Confluence
    • Roy Oakes: A Life Given
    • Transcape
    • Toxic Tour of Texas
    • The Magic Valley
    • Time Shadows of Ancient Greece
    • Firescape
  • FIRESCAPE BLOG
  • Bio
  • Contact
    Portfolios
      El Agua es La Vida: A Village Life Portrait
      Exit West: A Cultural Confluence
      Roy Oakes: A Life Given
      Transcape
      Toxic Tour of Texas
      The Magic Valley
      Time Shadows of Ancient Greece
      Firescape
    FIRESCAPE BLOG
SHARON STEWART
photography
    Bio
    Contact
Toxic Tour of Texas
Portfolio is empty Upload Images

MOTIVATIONS, REFLECTIONS, & STRATEGIES   |  EXHIBITIONS, PUBLICATIONS, & COLLECTIONS

Title
THE TOXIC TOUR OF TEXAS JOURNIES THROUGH A STATE THAT PRIDES itself in being the biggest, the best. And it is. Texas has the largest concentration of oil refineries and chemical plants in the nation. Texas ranks first in the United States in the amount of known or suspected carcinogens released into the environment. Texas also leads the nation in the number of hazardous waste disposal sites, seventy percent of which leak and threaten groundwater. And Texas industry discharges the highest level of toxic air emissions in the country.

The guides on this tour are farmers, priests, mothers, ranchers, engineers, nurses, and teachers who are intent on protecting their land, air, water, health, homes, and communities from exposure to hazardous waste. Their activism crosses social, economic, and racial boundaries. This coalition from the 90s aligns the century’s labor, civil rights, women’s, peace, and ecology movements.

These citizen activists have influenced and reversed governmental decisions. They have halted harmful industrial practices. They have changed their personal lifestyles, habits, and attitudes as a model of shared responsibility for maintaining and cherishing life on Earth.

• • •

Communities

Panna Maria


Fort Hancock


Brazoria County


Karnes County


Robstown


South Dallas County


TEXARKANA

Panhandle


Fort Bend County


Texas City

KARNES COUNTY


• • •


We did not know what we were going to do to defend ourselves, except get up there and say what we know about the tailings pond.

Here we are going to a hearing; no financial assistance from the county because we were told it was illegal, no assistance of any kind. 

We were going it alone.


– Forrest Balser, Rancher


ALL COMMUNITIES


PANHANDLE


• • •


If the workers at Pantex were more educated, they would refuse to do some of these things. I would have refused if I had known.

If people know it could cause sickness, they are not going to step up and say, “Here, take my life!”


– John Bell, Former Pantex Machinist


   ALL COMMUNITIES


FORT HANCOCK


• • •


Again and again, the echoing question of, “Why here?” rang though my ears as I stood atop the Diablo Rim looking

into the beautiful West Texas sunset. Clearly, any proud Texan, if they stood there, would be moved to say,

“This is not the place; this is unjust.”


– District Judge William Moody



ALL COMMUNITIES


ROBSTOWN


• • •


Now you’ve got pollution and contamination in the groundwater.

We are led to believe that the water knows where the boundary is, and it stops right there, and won’t cross that line.


– Kenneth Ahlrich, Member, PROTEC




ALL COMMUNITIES


FORT BEND COUNTY


• • •


Concerned Citizens Against Pollution is now recognized as a group that can pressure, promote, or defeat politicians and legislation, if necessary.


– Evelyn Freund, Former Municipal Judge




ALL COMMUNITIES

BRAZORIA COUNTY


• • •


We fear that there may be many abandoned oil wells in the area that were drilled before records were kept.

So, we don’t know if they were capped, so stored toxins could migrate.


– Doris McFadden




ALL COMMUNITIES

Sharon Stewart, Former Dal Tile Site

SOUTH DALLAS COUNTY


• • •


Educating the community is the most important thing.

You have to teach them, “Don’t be the Reactor, be the Actor.” It is so fulfilling how excited they are.


– Lorrie Coterill, President

Groups Allied to Stop Pollution (GASP)




ALL COMMUNITIES


TEXAS CITY


• • •


The Texas Water Commission is charged to prevent pollution.

That’s what the Clean Water Act says to do. They do not prevent pollution.

They permit pollution, taking on the notion that it must be balanced with economic development,

and I agree with them, but let’s add in the true cost, which is a reduced productive environment.

It’s a tremendous cost, a huge subsidy.


–Brian Cain, Resource Contaminant Specialist

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service



  ALL COMMUNITIES 



TEXARKANA


• • •


Most of the people who live out here were aware that this had been the site of a creosote treatment plant. They were not aware

of the hazards that were involved with the place being reclaimed for residential use.


– Jeter Steger, Resident



ALL COMMUNITIES


• • •

prints

20 x 16 Selenium Toned Gelatin Silver Photographs with Text

Open Editions

• • •

SELECTED EXHIBITIONS

Devour the Land: War and American Landscape Photography Since 1970  Harvard Art Museums  Cambridge


Time Returns: A Continuous Now   Everson Museum of Art  Syracuse


The Edge of the Earth: Climate Change in Photography and Video  Ryerson Image Center  Toronto


Altered Landscape: Photographs in a Changing Environment Nevada Museum of Art  Reno


Contemporary Women Photographers   Museum of Fine Arts Houston


Toxic Tour of Texas  Diverse Works Artspace  Houston


The Country Between Us  Massachusetts College of Art  Boston


Landscape at Risk  Houston Center for Photography  Houston


Landscape, Culture, and Politics  New Mexico State University  Las Cruces


Legacy of Choices in a Technological Era  Los Angeles Center for Photographic Studies  Los Angeles


Arid Waters: Photos from the Water in the West Project  University of Colorado Boulder


What Have We Done? Film in the Cities  St. Paul


Shot in El Paso: Contemporary Photographers on the Border  El Paso Museum of Art


The Altered Landscape: The Carol Franc Buck Collection  Nevada Museum of Art  Reno


Equal Justice  film by NAACP


Shifting Landscapes  SW Collection Special Collections Library  Texas Tech University


Toxic Tour of Texas Texas General Land Office and Texas Photographic Society  Austin


• • •

TOURING EXHIBITIONS

Toxic Tour of Texas  Texas Humanities Resource Center and the Texas Photographic Society


Toxic Landscapes: Artist Examine the Environment   The Puffin Foundation


Mobile Museum of the Nuclear Age  Foundation for a Compassionate Society


The Altered Landscape: The Carol Franc Buck Collection  Nevada Museum of Art


• • •

PRESENTATIONS

Earth Day at the Texas State Capitol


Texas Under Nuclear Siege Convention


Gubernatorial Candidate Ann Richards’ Environmental Policy Committee


First Statewide Meeting of the Texas Populist Alliance


Uranium Cycle Briefings to Legislators & Press  Texas Campaign for Global Security


Physicians for Social Responsibility  Texas Medical Association Annual Conference


Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers Union District 4 Meeting


4-H District Four Spectra Leadership Conference


University of Texas School of Public Health


About the Earth: Concepts of a Complex Nature  SPE South Central Regional Conference


Documenting Southern Communities  SPE 28th National Conference


Art & the Environment: Constructing New Paradigms  SPE Northeast Regional Conference


Women and Their Relationship to the Land  Women in Photography Conference


Text as Image, Image as Text  1999 National Graduate Seminar  American Photography Institute


• • •


ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Photography Fellowship  Mid-America Arts Alliance and National Endowment for the Arts


Artist-in-Residence Fellowship Light Work


Invitation to membership  Water in the West Project and Archive


Invitation to membership  Impact Visuals Photographic Cooperative


Visiting Master Artist  Texas Photographic Society


• • •

COLLECTIONS

Southwest Collection  Special Collections Library  Texas Tech University


Center for Creative Photography  University of Arizona


Harry Ransom Humanities Research Center  University of Texas-Austin


Harvard Art Museums


Museum of Fine Arts Houston


Worcester Art Museum


The Light Work Collection


New Mexico State University


The Altered Landscape: The Carol Franc Buck Collection  Nevada Museum of Art


PaineWebber American Land Use Collection John Szarkowski, Curator


• • •

PUBLICATIONS

Makeda Best, Devour the Land: War and Landscape Photography Since 1970, Harvard Art Museums, Cambridge, 2021


Bénédicte Ramade, The Edge of the Earth: Climate Change in Photography and Video, black dog, London, 2016


Anne M. Wolf, Altered Landscape: Photographs of a Changing Environment, Skira Rizzoli, New York, 2011


David Todd and David Weisman, The Texas Legacy Project, Texas A&M Press, College Station, 2010


Peter E. Poole, The Altered Landscape, University of Nevada Press, Reno, 1999


Pete A.Y. Gunter and Max Oelschlaeger, Texas Land Ethics, University of Texas Press, Austin, 1997


Lucy R. Lippard, Undertones: Nine Cultural Landscapes, Reframings: New American Feminist Photographies,

Diane Neumaier, Temple University Press, Philadelphia, 1995


Nancy Barrett, New Orleans Triennial: New Southern Photography, New Orleans Museum of Art, New Orleans, 1992


Laura McPhee and Barbara Bosworth, The Country Between Us: Contemporary American Landscape Photographs,

Massachusetts College of Art, Boston, 1992


Sharon Stewart, Toxic Tour of Texas, Houston, 1992



MOTIVATIONS, REFLECTIONS, AND  STRATEGIES

• • •

Father Frank Kurzaj

Panna Maria

    I CAME TO PANNA MARIA knowing environmental catastrophe from my native region, Silesia, in Poland. My brother has two mentally sick children. It is harder over here to get some results because of this strong connection with the political lobby. In Poland, it was only a problem with money, but everybody understood or knew that something was wrong. But the bottom line was we did not have money, so nothing could be done. Here, I believe the money is not the biggest problem; the politics is the biggest problem.

      For me personally, being involved in this is a continuation of my work as a Christian minister. I have a responsibility not only toward the soul, but also for the well-being of these people. This is a part of my ministry. So, from this point of view, I know that I have to do this work, and nothing will stop me from continuing if I see any solution. I decided a couple of years ago that this work would take at least six, seven, maybe ten years. So as long as I’m here in Panna Maria, I will probably be working on this. We can only take steps one after the other.

       We cannot solve the problems in one year, one month, or one regulatory hearing. I would like to encourage everyone 

who has something like this, or is watching or looking around, to see that problems similar like this exist, to start now, because it takes time.

       So what we are doing? We are trying to know something about our health, and for this reason we are doing the health study. We are trying to know something about the aquifer, so we are working on this hydrological study. We believe that finally the state representatives and the state agencies will listen to us when we have this information, and unfortunately not now, but in six or ten years from now they will do something here. This is how it works in Texas.

       I am very pleased with this health study. People who were on the other side of this issue, now are seeing and listening. Even the people who are working at the uranium mill tailings pond are seeing that we are only trying to discover the truth. We are not on the side of the industry; we are not on the side of the church; we are trying only to learn the truth of what is happening here.

ANDY RIVES

Panna Maria

     SINCE 1988, when the Panna Maria Concerned Citizens was formed, we have developed a community awareness that the uranium industry is not a benign industry. It does more than tear up the earth and leave big holes behind. We have slowly brought the community more together in some ways...and apart in others. They don’t seem to realize the uranium industry is just short term employment here. In 20 years the uranium will play out, and we are left behind with land, that for all practical purposes, is dead. They don’t understand that whenever you kill the land, sooner or later you’re gonna be killin’ the people that’s around the land. So, we are trying to find out what the potential damage to this area is, and who is responsible.

     I talked with Chevron’s lobbyist in Austin, and asked if they would sit down with us and talk about restriction on their license. He said yes. We had a rough and rocky start at first, but I felt we were able to get something accomplished.

     Chevron agreed not to take waste other than uranium mill tailing ore such as the black acid they were bringing in on their rail spur. They agreed to put in more air monitors around the site and to drill more water monitoring wells. They brought in an hydrologist to look into the seepage at the southwest corner of the tailings pond. At the relicensing hearing they acknowledged there was a problem with seepage and that there should be ways to find a solution.

     Other things we did...we got the Texas Department of Health to test all of the water wells in the area to establish background levels of radioactivity, heavy metals, and solvents in order to have a baseline from which to compare in future years. We also asked for similar testing on the air and surrounding vegetation, and we got them to control the stench from that pond.

      We were very instrumental in lobbying legislators to get this chromosomal aberration study done in order to find out the effects of long term exposure to low dosages of radiation. And we have really quieted down in the past year because of the study. We want it to be an unbiased study, not wanting anyone to refuse to participate because they thought we were associated with it. There are some people who would make that connection, and would not participate because they think we would want to shut this plant down and their sons, brothers, cousins, and nephews and nieces would not have a place to work.

      If there is a negative determination from this health study, and I dearly hope everything is fine, I think you will see greater support for Panna Maria Concerned Citizens. Perhaps the mill would have to be shut down. People, yes, would lose their jobs, and that’s something we don’t want, but you can always find another job; you can’t go out and find another life.

FORREST & MARY JO BALSER

Karnes County

        WE WERE AWARE they at the Conoco Conquista uranium mill tailings site were doing a little extra dumping after they had closed down the uranium milling operation. And when they tried to transfer the license to people who had worked there before...well, we thought, “If you are not going to use it yourself, you should shut it down.”

      We read about the proposed license transferral in the Texas Register, and we only had a short time before going to the hearing. What we managed to do was get a continuance on the hearing to have more time to know the factors involved. We wondered how a license to dump could be transferred when it was expired. Yes, they were operating on a timely renewal status, but we think finally Conoco got so much bad publicity over this, that they decided not to attempt to go through with it. They would have had to go through the whole process of relicensing.

    We did obtain help from the Texas Department of Agriculture and the Attorney General’s office on this. And 

we held fund raising barbeques and dances to defray the costs of challenging the license transferral. Though, quite a lot did come from our own pockets, with the total cost coming to about $75,000. There are only so many donuts you can sell...The whole problem really was trying to get the county judge and the commissioners behind us, which they never did.

      In these kinds of situations, we have hope for the younger people who can carry on. We’ll do what we can, but we won’t be here forever. We do have a love for the land. Growing up in a rural area is what we’ve known all our lives. God made it beautiful, and we don’t like it when it’s polluted and ruined for personal gain and greed. We don’t know how long this can go on-this selfishness-until there’s nothing left to take. It gets down to, in our minds, what is right and what is wrong, and when we sense something is wrong, we are determined to do something about it.

LES BREEDING

PANHANDLE

     PRACTICING CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE for me is part of an overall strategy, with many parts to it. One is, and it is one of the early stages, is to actually place yourself in the position of being arrested. It is a very strong way to bring initial attention to an issue that needs to be brought into focus publicly. It’s a way of dramatically showing that this deserves attention, and illustrates the fact that these people feel so strongly about this, that this is such a bad deal, they are willing to go to jail for it by standing up in the strongest way they know. And this needs to be coupled with other kinds of political action of creating a larger mass movement that can actually work politically, and start changing the system.

     We have a secondary purpose, and that is to make it so that other people can be involved in civil disobedience without having to put themselves at as much risk as what we did. We certainly have not paid a huge price, but we have put ourselves at a lot more risk than most people can really handle by facing six months in jail.

     Our goal is to educate the people of the county that this is that big of a deal, folks. These are people being arrested for praying in front of a weapons facility.

     We can all get used to this is idea. And if you want to cart us off the road, or give us a ticket, or want to throw us in jail overnight, that’s ok, but it seems pretty weird to tell people you are going to put them in jail for six months, which was the very strong message the prosecutors were giving initially. We are a very non-violent group; we are intentionally non-violent, and there’s no way we will be anything but non-violent.

     The arrest stance does not necessarily need to take place at the beginning, it can be at any time in the process; it can be used several times in the process. Most of the time people do it in the beginning so that it can get that initial attention that an issue needs so that the people that will be interested in the issue will come to it. Like in the civil rights days; they needed to start off with boycotts and lunch counter sit-ins and such, so that down through time, after the mass movement was created, they were able to push through the Civil Rights Act in Congress. And those actions needed to happen. Unfortunately, these actions still need to happen.

IGNACIO ESCANDÓN

EL PASO

     EPISO (EL PASO INTERRELIGIOUS SPONSORING ORGANIZATION) is all the people who participate from all the church communities. The church out in Ft. Hancock has representatives to the executive committee from that church. We participate as an organization in the effort to stop the low level nuclear waste disposal site from being built there. They take the lead as the church that is there near the site. As an organization, we never go in to help unless the people ask us in. We then bring our efforts toward organizing and toward putting a strategy to be used.

       We don’t participate by throwing money at a problem. We participate by testifying at public hearings; by putting together meetings to explain to the people what has happened; by bringing the elected officials or decision makers before the people to present what they need to say. Perhaps even more importantly at the local level, we are involved with the political process by holding accountability sessions when people are up for re-election. By getting them to say how they feel  about  an

issue then later on when they get elected, if elected, they fall back or change positions, we can always go back and hold them accountable. Even though we cannot force them to honor their word, it is a public embarrassment for them to be sited for not doing what they promised to do.

     We are nonpartisan in that we work within the political system without supporting candidates or parties. We do voter registration and get-out-to-vote efforts prior to important elections around issues that especially affect our membership. The newspapers and the media recognize that EPISO is an organization that takes tough stands on a number of issues. And we are a force to be reckoned with because we represent such a cross section of the community, albeit most of it in this town, Hispanic and poor, and from churches south of the freeway. More and more people are beginning to recognize that we are the only organization willing to take on these very tough questions about quality of life issues.

IRMA DOMINGUEZ

FORT HANCOCK

     THE PEOPLE ACROSS THE (RIO GRANDE) RIVER were just so elated that we were successful in keeping the (low level radioactive waste) site from Ft. Hancock. I think this situation just broadened and strengthened the bonds we had and have now. Those in El Porvenir were a large part of the victory because it showed that even though the river is a border, it really isn’t. In essence there are no borders in a situation of this nature.

      Grassroots groups traditionally come and go, and are usually very issue oriented. And besides the word, grassroots, we (EPISO of the Industrial Areas Foundation) like the word “institutionalized” because grassroots connotes a certain kind of image, and I think it’s important for everyone to understand that it wasn’t just a grassroots effort, it was something coming 

from within the system as church-based, and family unit-based. One of the most important things we learned is that regular people who are part of these systems already can just go ahead and focus and tune in on these issues through their institutions. And what better institutions for justice than the church and the family?

       Once you have a self-interest in a situation, it becomes a prioritized issue for you and your family. Whereas, if someone else comes in and does the work for you, the appreciation is not there. Your involvement builds self-esteem and empowerment. Empowerment is so necessary because you develop a sense that nobody is going to walk over you and that you can succeed.

MARY ALCORN

FORT HANCOCK

     WHAT DOES IT TAKE to do this work? A whole lot of stick-to-itness. As discouraging as it gets, try not to let it get you down. Keep at it. Strength; that comes from family and friends. Unfortunately, in a deal like this, you find out who your friends are, and who aren’t. But, you do find new friends and new strengths.

      I did a whole lot of soul searching to determine if what I felt and what we were doing was right, and that provided me with a lot of strength. You find strength where you didn’t know you had it, both in yourself, and in your friends and family. It’s just pure dedication. If you think you are right, you have to keep going, and there were times it was pretty darn hard. I would think, “I just give up!” Then a week would go by, and I’d calm down a little bit and say, “I can’t let them get away with this; I just can’t.”

      My first reaction to the idea of siting a low level dump here was, “I don’t like this at all.” I was naive and easily snowed, and I sat back and thought, “Let’s see what happens before I get all upset about it.” And lo and behold, suddenly I realized sittin’ back and waiting for what was to happen was just cuttin’ my own throat, because the Authority’s way of doing business specifically was to go as fast forward as they could. They did not make things real open and aware to us until it was too late for us to do something about it. They kept saying we would have these public hearings, and we would have input, and I kind of believed them. Then it dawned on me that by the time they came around to having the public input, it was getting to be a moot issue because the wheels would have turned so far.

      What first of all happened, they hadn’t even picked the site. They had it narrowed down to three or four places and that’s what keep me hanging back for so long. It took them so long to ”officially” pick a site, and I was waiting for them to officially pick one, and I thought they would be honest and on 

the up and up, and then we’ll talk about it. Well, as it turned out, they were kind of snowing us; they had picked our site unofficially, quietly, for a long, long time, and knew they were going with that site, and the others were covers, I guess you would say. And that’s what put me off. If I had known from the very beginning that they had ultimately picked our site, I would have jumped in with both feet.

      Educating myself occurred slowly and painfully. Lots and lots of letters were written, and lots of phone calls were made. We went to Austin and met with anybody we could think of that could have a bearing on this, or give us advice. Talk about an education! We started kind of in the middle with our local legislators and worked up and down from there. We met with the Governor’s office, Lt. Governor’s staff, Attorney General, Bureau of Radiation Control, Texas Water Commission, Sierra Club.

      The interesting thing is, I was kinda concerned that it would be real hard to get in and see people. Some we got in with EPISO’s help, but a lot of them, I just did myself over the phone. I called and said, “I’m Mary Alcorn, and I’m coming to Austin, and I’d like to meet with you.” Most of them, almost without exception, were more than willing to meet. You kind of think of them as real inaccessible, and there are a few that are, but one way or the other, through staff or whatever, if you really keep after them, it is not that hard to meet with them. Followup is also very important so they know you are seriously concerned.

     Most of what happened in our case was good fortune and luck from the people who stayed with it. A lot of strings were being pulled from enough directions. Diversity is important too. Garner support from as many groups as you can because the more they hear from more different groups, the more impact it has. What is it they say that there’s safety in numbers?

KENNETH AHLRICH

ROBSTOWN

     I’M JUST SO DOWN AND OUT, you have no idea how frustrated and washed out I feel with all of this. My lawsuit against TECO is about the contamination of off site underground water, and for the refusal of a bank loan for my farm operations, and the devaluation of my property now. I have a letter proving that my loan was refused because of the location of a toxic waste dump next to my property.

     What keeps me going is to protect  my  interest,  and  that

what they are doing is deadly wrong. It’s as wrong as if I was to go out there and run over somebody on the highway and kill ‘em, or if I would take my shotgun and be a sniper. I love the environment, and I see it being destroyed literally every day of my life being right here. Just the fact that they are in here, they are destroying the environment. Nobody can argue with me that it was better than it was before they were here in this particular area.

HAROLD McVEY

fort bend county

     WE HAVE LIVED HERE in these sleepy communities for 20, 30, up to 50 years, and all of the sudden garbage dumps are popping up, hazardous waste is being reclassified...and we get concerned, and that’s because we are not educated. I tell you though, you go to Austin to a couple of those (Texas) Water Commission hearings, and you get an education real fast.

     Now, it’s up to the commissioners of counties where these things are showing up to be informed. Your county judge and your commissioners are ruling this, and they are our elected officials. They control your county. They can talk to the Governor. But if they are not careful, they can be bribed through ignorance, too. It is their responsibility to stay with this. The commissioners of Wharton County must be credited for staying with this fight.

     And if we don’t form these little coalitions like Concerned Citizens Against Pollution and Defenders of the Environment, these things can come about without anyone knowing what happened. You need concerned people.

    I’m still in favor of the industry that manufactures this material with their byproducts as being more capable of handling it either by recycling and by disposing of it, rather than these little people who pop up here and want to make a fast buck by putting it into the ground. We don’t want to pollute the streams, and the rivers, or the underground streams. That is the bottom line.

EVELYN FREUND

Fort bend County

      THE FIRST THING YOU NEED is a group that is not divided.  Select a president. Put your trust in him or her, and don’t try to grab the glory. Every organization has one or two people that wants to hog the mike, I guess is what you would say. So, keep the group together and do not let inside conflicts detract you from the project as a whole. Also, do not get discouraged, because it is common practice that these people are gonna try to buy your local government, and worm their way in before you can really do anything, and you don’t have any money. You just have to stick with it. It’s all gotta be done on a shoestring, as you well know.

     • • •

DORIS McFADDEN

BRAZORIA COUNTY

     FIRST OF ALL, what you must do is take a good look at the situation and see if it’s something that’s going to be harmful to your area. If you decide it is, get opinions from people who know about the conditions of the land and the water, and what the effect of the proposed operation would be on them. We got a geologist to look at the faults around here. We did a lot of investigating. We hired a good lawyer.

     You can find out a lot of things by going to the county courthouse, and looking at records to see if there’s any adverse liens against the people proposing the facility. See what their business reputation is, and what experience they have. So many times you can talk directly with people, although I never talked directly to these folks. We just started having meetings here in the subdivision to discuss the situation; trying to get a sense of how the people felt about it. When we decided to organize, we got the information on how to start a non-profit organization. You don’t have to get a non-profit charter, but I think it is to your advantage. Then you apply to the federal government for non-profit status, and then all the donations you get are tax deductible for the people who give them. I think this helps.

     Raising money is the hard part. We held fund raising dances, auctions, accepted contributions, and sponsored a booth at the Harvest Festival selling hot chocolate and baked goods. Our membership cost $5 per person and $10 per family. We kept it low because we didn’t want anybody who wanted to be members to be excluded.

      At some point in time, and I think the time is now, we must start looking into the future. We don’t want to put the industries out of business. We desperately need the industries, but we do want them to clean up their act. We want a safer environment for the workers. We want a safer place for our homes and for our future generations. And remember this, industry may contribute the big campaign bucks, but the people elect the officials, and it’s time that we send out the signals about what we expect of them. We must have laws to protect us. We must have elected officials who will stand up and be counted, and we must have industries that will reduce, recycle, and neutralize waste, and properly dispose of the small amount that is left. These things we insist on, and these things we must have.

JUDGE JOHN DAMON

Brazoria County

      I KNOW THAT THERE'S SOME OF YOU in this room who will profit monetarily from this injection well, and that’s what makes this country go round...the capitalistic system. But I would encourage everybody not to let a short term gain create a long term loss. Brazoria County is going to continue to fight this well, and I hope we bring it to a successful conclusion. Nothing is certain, but that you have to fight this well.

     • • •

LORA PONCIK

Brazoria County

     YOU DO WHAT YOU GOTTA DO. We went into this with our eyes open. All you are doin’ is protectin’ your land, and there’s very few precious things that’s left. It’s not gold or silver, but you eat off the fat of the land. That’s your livin’. And I don’t care if it’s an inch; it’s yours.

     • • •

LORRIE COTERILL

South dallas County

    THERE'S NOTHING THAT MAKES YOU more charged than seeing people empower themselves. I tell them, “The power is y’all’s, guys. Take it. Don’t give it away.” I think one of the things, too, is that with Ann’s (Richards) election, these agency people started seeing the power of the people. And I think there’s a lot of power in people. I see some things that have changed in the Health Department just since staff started getting active like pulling citizens into hearings. Our system is built for public participation. It’s the balance of the scales.

  And some of my most satisfying work? Beatin’ Waste Management, bustin’ Dal Tile, and staying on the Texas Health Department (TDH) enough about suspected groundwater contamination at the South Dallas County site. We requested split test samples from both the TDH and them, and they went for it. These were the first split samples done in Texas, and now it is the norm. Keepin’ the Red Barnes dump out, too. That was a 1,000 acre dump that was to come in this area. Because we are establishing a reputation...that’s the whole idea...they realized our power and backed off. You’ve got to get a reputation about not tolerating being dumped on.

      But with Laidlaw, our community is too split. We have two different groups in this city. It became a war of the groups. That’s the divide and conquer routine, and that’s what the companies want because that’s what’s effective. But from Laidlaw, what it did was open our eyes and made it so we could go into other communities with our knowledge. Like Save Our Community over there in Ferris that kept Waste Management from expanding their dump. We helped them set up and organize.

    You wanna know what keeps me goin’? God does. God gives me the energy and the drive, and when people say they are so tired, I just seem to reach down in my pocket and there’s more strength. And the more I am into it, I wonder why God puts the people together that He puts together. You know, sometimes things happen that are not scientifically explainable...You educate your community and tell them what’s happening, and then let them make educated choices. We are definitely stewards of the land.

RITA CARLSON

TEXAS CITY 

     THIS MOVE TO GALESBURG, Illinois has changed me so much, because now I understand the problem better than I did before. Before I moved, it was all, “Get the industry and make them stop! They’ve got to change their production, and the way they make these chemicals; they’ve got to change the way they get rid of these chemical byproducts.” And now I see that the whole secret is to get people to understand what is happening along the Texas-Louisiana coast. You never hear it talked about, you never hear it mentioned, that over 60% of the chemicals produced in the U.S. come from that five county area down there.

     Getting to people and making them understand how what is happening down there is going to affect their lives, even though they live a thousand, two thousand miles away. I do not know the secret to that, but until we make people all over the U.S. understand what’s happening where these chemicals are produced, and how it is going to degrade their lifestyle, these ways of manufacturing are going to continue.

      It’s going to take a nationwide change in lifestyle. How the environmental groups get this across to the nation is the key, because at this point, people are not believing what the environmental groups are saying. I don’t know how to wake people up, but that is what it is gonna take. People have to stop buying these plastic products. They have to stop puttin’ their money into things that are hurting people. Changing their lifestyle is the whole secret, because once these companies start feeling it in their pocketbook, they’ll stop producing. But as long as people keep buyin’ these products, and turnin’ a deaf ear and a blind eye to what these environmental groups are sayin’, it’s going to continue.  There’s too many people out

there participating and continuing the cycle with their money. And there’s too many people in this nation going on with their day to day business, and just not listening.

      Whole programs come on television every week dealing with environmental issues, so it’s not like the information isn’t put out there in front of people; it’s just that they aren’t listening. So what’s the secret to makin’ people’s minds click? It’s just like my husband, Mike, and I said a month after we were in this in Texas City. It’s gonna take dead bodies on the sidewalks. It’s gonna take little children laying in hospital beds that are deformed and sick from these odors and waste.

      People have blinders on. They are in a complete state of denial. I talk about this every minute I can, and people up here in Illinois look at me like I’m from another planet. You can see it in their mannerisms that they think I am manufacturing this stuff up in my head; that no human being would do that to another; that these companies would not knowingly poison the ground and not knowingly poison the water where fish are taken for human consumption.

      So, what to do? Get these scientists out there talking. Push ‘em to get scientific studies and documentation done on the fish and the people. Scientific data is the only thing you can rely on when you are pushed against the wall. We need doctors who are willing to talk, and not be worried about the money they will lose by opening their mouths. Get these doctors out there to talk about the health effects they see on the populations that live around these petrochemical plants. The bottom line is to work on people, and find the secret to make them understand that these issues are true and real, and we are all affected.

BARBARA & GLENN ERWIN

Texas City 

     THE LINK WE FOUND in forming Environment 2000 that we have not had in the past is the ability to incorporate organized labor in with the environmental groups. We had so much in common, and so much of the same goals, that we needed some vehicle to interact and network. The membership of organized labor usually does not tend to perceive itself as ones who would join the existing environmental groups.

      Environmental groups have tended to come together to fight something, and then they disband. So a lot of times they carry negative names, as well as negative connotations. People have felt they have been at odds with everybody...with parts of the community, as well as whoever they were fighting against. That’s not always the case, but it’s the perceived idea that you go in with. The people we want to bring in are those that have not traditionally been in environmental groups, as well as members of the minority communities.

      For awhile there were no effective environmental groups here, because people, for the longest time thought, “That’s money you smell.” Yes, money for the doctors and the undertakers, but it does not have to be that way. People were conditioned here that if you wanted the job, you had to take the pollution with it. And it is no more that way. People want to do something. They think they can do recycling, but never before have they thought they could do something that could change their air or their water; it was something they had no control over. Environment 2000 was organized to educate the community on their rights.

      A lot of the environmental groups would have no consideration as far as the jobs of the plant workers. If a plant is a polluter, why, their goal would be to just shut it down. Our goal would be to clean it up. We both have the objective of having a cleaner environment, but our methods would be different. Through this group we would like to get our message to the environmental groups that we have a concern for jobs. I think we can make a lot of gains by working within the structure and forming the alliance between the environmentalists and the labor groups.

      I attended a meeting with local residents and there was such a sense of frustration to do something about the situation here, and there was no vehicle in this town to do it. People who live and work here know that they are having problems, and there was nowhere to go to address that. With Environment 2000, we can show them that we can do positive things, and we can do it on a local level.

      And that’s how we want to keep it, is local. That way there is not the perception that outsiders are coming in, which the media often uses against them. Being associated with a national group carries the outsider name, and that can be a problem when you are talking to the press, industry, business leaders, or community people.

      The first thing I said in organizing this group is that I do not want to be against anything. I want to do something entirely different. If we have something we want to see changed, we will present an alternative to it. If there is a viable alternative, we ought to push to have it, but we have to be educated enough to know to look for it.

      People basically resist change. We want the new, but we want to remain the same; that’s the dichotomy in people. People resist change unless they see there can be a difference. We have long term goals, and we are focusing on short term goals, too, and when people see the positiveness in that it can be done, the momentum builds.

      Glenn ran for mayor and we were talking to people, and I guess the number one issue they were talking about was they wanted a cleaner environment. They realized they did not want to make the choice of jobs or bad environment anymore, and they were not happy with what was not being done. Everybody knows that Texas City blew up in `47, and we’ve had a couple of minor explosions. Minor, not that people weren’t killed, but they were related to industry; they stayed within the plant boundaries with units blowing up. And everybody had this false security that it wasn’t going to happen to them, or in this town. But I think Bhopal helped with that awareness, because people began to think this could really happen here, and then the hydrofluoric acid spill brought to mind that it really can happen here. 

      People were very frustrated that the sirens did not go off for 30 minutes after the spill. Alot of people were really hurt and are still having side effects, and although it is difficult to prove there is a direct relation, people know they are having problems, and they wanted to see something done. Then after the elections, the city government did not move towards the area of doing anything, so we decided maybe this environmental group would help.

      We have established the Action Center for Toxics. We have brought in the medical community, the legal profession, and organized labor to create a place where any employee, any resident that has a problem or thinks there is a problem, will be able to come and get help ranging from medical advice to arranging for a good attorney because it takes a good attorney to try a toxic tort case.

      We would also like industry to come and face the people in the town in a public forum and answer any and all questions on a quarterly basis. If they want to hear the hostilities, so be it. And out of that you will also hear things people would like to see that are positive. And I’d like to see when we have elections, to have the candidates come and talk only about environmental issues. “What are you going to do for the environment? What have you done in the past for the environment? What are your plans? How involved have you been or has it just been lip service?” This is new, and has not been done before. I think our representatives have to be held accountable to environmental issues. And if you don’t hold them accountable, nobody else will.

      You have to have national legislation to back up your concerns. Sometimes industry has carried a negative connotation because of what they have not done. But they do make changes many times because they have to by law, and that’s good. We have the Clean Air Act. We have SARA Title III (Right-to-Know). We have the Texas Clean Air Act. We need to have those because sometimes industry does things to benefit themselves, but it still it also benefits us. And we will acknowledge the companies when they do do positive things.

      There is no more a choice between a job and clean air and clean water. People now want clean air and clean water and their job, and I think that is a moving concern in a lot of places, as well as Texas City. Yes, we want to live here and we love it, but we want to stay. We are not looking to run somewhere else where it may or may not be cleaner. People have to stay here. We came here because of employment. We like it here. We ‘re staying here, and we want to see a cleaner environment. We raised our children here. It is better than it was when we moved here.

PATSY OLIVER

Texarkana

       SO MANY PEOPLE don’t think that one person can make a difference, and really it has to start someplace, so let it start with me. There was a Sunday school lesson on TV one morning, and I was sitting there reminiscing and contemplating a lot of things, and this message came. I thought, “Lord, send me. I’ll go. I’ll try.”

      At first I became a member of FUSE (Friends United for a Safe Environment), and now I’ve gone all the way to national with being on the National Toxics Campaign Board. Four or five years ago I never thought my life would be affected in such a way. Ever since losing my mother, I became more involved. I became more determined to make a difference because I said I owe this to her. Now I’m in this for life. There’s no way I’ll get out. It’s the only thing I know. It’s an ongoing thing; an ongoing education everyday.

We had a wonderful, wonderful summit in Washington, D.C. last October (The United Church of Christ’s Peoples’ Summit). It was multi-cultural, multi-racial, multi-everything. The march up to Capitol Hill...beautiful, very spiritual. The Lord met us there. He took us all away. This work has to be with you spiritually because if you are in it for the glory, there is no need in even thinking about it. There’s a lot of late hours, a lot of sacrifices to be made. But you are going to be part of a tradition. It’s an ongoing, ongoing thing. And that’s where you get your feeling from.

      You start with one thing, and find small accomplishments and satisfaction doing it, and before you know it, you are so wrapped up in it, it becomes a part of you.

    It’s like a second skin really. You go through so many hardships and you can identify and be empathetic with so many people, that when you thought you were out there alone and powerless, it gives you a certain identity. I think that’s the only way I can say it.

      And then it makes you stronger with yourself. You come from being an “hysterical housewife” one day to being a person that says, “No, we are going to make a difference.” And you stop becoming an “I” person, then you become a “we” person, and it changes your whole life. It’s a marriage of sorts. It really is. You are reborn. That’s the way I feel.

      This a part of my life that destroyed the part that I thought was good. I found out that I wouldn’t be able to put my life together in a whole way that I would like, but I’m not going to give up. Then you find others who have just as bad off or even worse than you. And these types of environmental and human health problems are happening everywhere; all over. It’s a universal thing; a global thing. And you say, “Oh, this wouldn’t happen to us in the United States. We are U.S. citizens. This is America.” But this is where it’s happening all the time. We just aren’t aware of it.

       You know, people are votes, and if we are ever going to remain doing things in the American way, within the system we have in place, we must vote. And if you can’t talk to them and make a difference, you can vote them out; one or the other. And put someone in who knows at least how you are feeling. If you don’t then you won’t have a world anymore because we are destroying it from within. It’s ignorance and neglect. Well, it’s a lot of things.

PANNA MARIA

• • •

I have been drinking this water for nine years.
What am I going to do, truck in water for a family of ten?

– Lailey Sczepanik, Member
Panna Maria Concerned Citizens

   ALL COMMUNITIES 


17,500 Pound Load Zoned Bridge Armstrong Road, Brazoria County Those of you who are familiar with this area know that once you reach Armstrong Road that is the only access road into the subdivision. Either way that you go to reach this area you have a narrow winding road with 90 degree angles, one way bridges, and weight zoned bridges. The road is traveled by our family cars and school buses. We think this poses serious safety problems, if the waste tanker tucks are going to use this road. — Doris McFadden, Retired Nurse Citizen Testimony EPA Hearing, April 13, 1990
i
Inquire about this Artwork